Urban Decay Super Saturated Ultra Intense Waterproof Cream Eyeliner in Perversion Review and Swatches

(0,1oz./3g - 22USD) Such a disappointment, I had high expectations buying this eyeliner because just like everyone else, I love Urban Decay's 24/7 glide on pencils too, unfortunately this cream one is no where near them.
My main problem is that, it's too stiff, dry and it tugs on my eyelids. Even applying on my arm it was a pain, such a shame, this is the one only product from Urban Decay that I hate.

Dior 5 Colors Designer Eyeshadow Palette in 708 Amber Design Review and Swatches

(0.15oz./4.4g - 59USD) I love how Dior makes these luxurious and convenient packagings. It's not bulky, it won't take unnecessary space plus it has a mirror inside. Comes with 2 double ended applicators, 3 ends have sponge tip and one of them has an eyeliner brush.
First shade on top left is amazing, one of my favorite brown eyeshadow ever. It has a velvety smooth texture, not powdery at all, blends seamlessly.  It has warm brown pearls even micro shimmers in it on a brown base.
Second shade on top right has a consistency that's very different than regular eyeshadows, it's something in between cream and powder eyeshadow. It has a very very sheer base color, almost invisible with a ton of champagne colored shimmers and glitters. It's better to use it with the sponge tip applicator otherwise it's hard to build up.
Third shade in the middle has a lot of pigmentation. Pale yellow gold with pale orange hue. It's a metallic shade.
Fourth shade on bottom left is almost as creamy as the second shade. It leans towards to sheer side. Pale gold and champagne shimmers on an ivory base.
Last but not least fifth shade is a blackened brown eyeliner. It's not comparable to MAC's or Bobbi Brown's gel liners but still it's usable. A bit dry, a bit sheer.

MAC Pearlglide Intense Eye Liner in Black Line & Black Swan Review and Swatches

(0.04oz./1.2g - 15USD) I don't typically like MAC pencil eyeliners but Pearlglides are an exception. I absolutely admire their formula. They just glide on effortlessly, with only one swipe you get an intense color pay-off. Once they are dry they don't smudge or budge. These are the MAC version of Urban Decay 24/7 eyeliners, which if you haven't already know they are amazing too, but not available worldwide. Black Line, it's a golden shimmered eyeliner on a black base and when these colors are together they almost look green in certain light. Black Swan is a black based eyeliner with grey and blue shimmers.

Inglot Matte Collection AMC Waterproof Eyeliner Gel Review and Swatches

This must be my number worst ever product, I truly regret buying it. Why in the hell I got an Inglot eyeliner instead of sticking to my good old Mac one's? And they cost almost the same! Even the packaging is poor, it's just a cheap plastic jar. The product is even worse! It's waterproof ok, cool. The consistency is a disaster, it's solid, tacky, sticky. You have to struggle to even coat your brush or fingers with it to use it as en eyeshadow and struggle even more to transfer it on to your eyelids and you want to blend it shape it and play with it, no! It won't let you. It sticks to where ever you put it. Eyelids are delicate, this product might work for body painting but certainly not for your eyelids.
I thought oh well then I'll use it as an eyeliner but no! You can't even coat your thin brush, even if you do after some time you can't draw a nice line, it won't glide on, it's so dry. I even swatched it in the store, it was again very dry but I thought it's open for how long, so normally it dried up, mşne will be brand new and creamy, so I ended up buying the worst product of my collection.

MAC Technakohl Liner in Purple Dash Review and Swatches

(0,35g/0,012oz. - 15USD) Urban Decay 24/7 are hands down my favorite eyeliners and everytime I try another brand I promise myself to be loyal to my UDs but my greediness wants to try out new things more often than my loyalty. I have tried every different type of MAC eye pencils and liners, only the Fluidline and Pearlglides work for me, other than these two, Mac is really bad at making a good eyeliner. For example this one is long lasting, smudge proof but it's not soft at all so you have to struggle to get an intense color, you have to pull your eyelids and stuff, I can't deal with that when I have my good old gel liners or UD 24/7s.
Talking about the shade, I'm a sucker for plums but I hate this formula as much as I love the shade, it's a plum with red/burgundy pearls.

Make Up Forever Aqua Eyes Eyeliner Pencil in 0L, 4L, 18L Review and Swatches

MUFE Aqua Eyes has great selection of shades, their only competition is Urban Decay 24/7 glide on pencils but they are a bit different. In the pictures there is two one swipe of the shade and heavily applied thicker swatch.
I think if your looking for a water proof eyeliner, this is it! But if your looking for an eyeliner, UD 24/7's should be your choice. Because it's softer, creamier, more pigmented.
0L Mat Black: Mat flat black, not as smooth as Urban Decay Zero but as pigmented if you keep applying it over and over.
4L: Purple plum with reddish purple sheen.
18L: Mat plummy red with tiny silver sparkles.

Plum Eyeliner Swatches and Comparisons

Maybelline Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner in Eggplant (3g/0,106 oz. - 9,99USD) : This shade is almost identical with Mac Macroviolet, the only difference is this one has more sheen to it and Mac is a little bit rich in color. But texture wise they are very different, Maybelline has a lot more drier formula.

Mac Fluidline in Macroviolet (3g/0,10 oz. - 15USD) : Mac fluidlines hands down are one of the best gel liners in the market. They have a very creamy texture, they will not dry very quickly. Macroviolet is a blackened violet with a subtle sheen.

Mac Fluidline in Dark Diversion (3g/0,10 oz. - 15USD) : Dark Diversion is a very rich burgundy with a lot of brown hue to it. It almost has no sheen. Is a very flattering alternative to your regular black liner.

Lancome Ink Artliner in Plum Tease (4g/0,14 oz. - 23,50USD) : This was part of Lancome's collection that came out in 2009, I'm just adding it because some of you may have this shade already. So this gel liner is a bit different in texture, it's hard to explain but almost has this mousse like texture maybe silicone based? I don't know. I like it though. Anyways this is a very pretty red-plum shade with a cream finish.

MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil in Bordeauxline Review and Swatches

Powerpoint eye pencils from MAC are a total failure for me, because the ones I've tried are SO hard to apply that you have to scratch your eyelid to get an even coat. The color though, is very pretty, a matte reddish plum.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on Eye Pencils in Bourbon Review and Swatches

(1.2g/0.04oz.-18USD) Bourbon is warm toned brown with tiny golden shimmers.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on Eye Pencils in Yeyo Review and Swatches

(1.2g/0.04oz.-18USD) I bought Yeyo to use on my waterline but it seems like it can't stay on my waterline, maybe it needs drier surface to stick to.
Yeyo is a metallic white color.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on Eye Pencils in Rockstar Review and Swatches

(1.2g/0.04oz.-18USD) This is my favorite shade out of all of them. Rockstar is dark, blackened plum with a slight metallic sheen. Sephora says that Rockstar is exclusive to them but I bought it at Ulta.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on Eye Pencils in Eldorado Review and Swatches

(1.2g/0.04oz.-18USD) Eldorado is a dark golden yellow shade and has a metallic finish. PErfect to use on the bottom lashline. You can even use them as an eyeshadow base, they are that smooth and long lasting.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on Eye Pencils in Crash Review and Swatches

(1.2g/0.04oz.-18USD) Crash is a dark purple with silver micro glitters.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on Eye Pencils in Stash Review and Swatches

(1.2g/0.04oz.-18USD) Stash is a green with golden micro glitters which makes the color more khaki like. Even one swipe gives you a perfect color, I can't get over how pretty these eyeliners are.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on Eye Pencils in Binge Review and Swatches

(1.2g/0.04oz.-18USD) This is a mini eye pencil which came with a set, but it's also available for individual purchase. Very pretty almost metallic midnight blue shade.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on Eye Pencils in Deviant Review and Swatches

(1.2g/0.04oz.-18USD) Unfortunately this amazing brand is not widely available, this is such a shame everyone deserves to own an eyeliner from UD.
Deviant is a bright blue color with silver micro glitters.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on Eye Pencils in Oil Slick Review and Swatches

(1.2g/0.04oz.-18USD) Everyone should own an Urban Decay eyeliner, they are the best. They glide on like butter and smudgable until they dry. But once they dry it won't move until you remove them. They are not waterproof but they stay on forever. Oil Slick is sheerer than the other colors but still very pigmented. It's dark grey with silver micro glitters.

Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Long Lasting Eyeliner in Violine #40 Review and Swatches

I really wanted this product to work but it didn't. It stays put and won't move BUT if you can apply it! This is literally the hardest eyeliner that I have ever used. You have to scratch your eyelid to put it on. I don't recommend this product to anyone and don't want anyone to spend their money on it.

Inglot Liquid Eyeliner #41 Silver Review and Swatches

(0,14fl oz./4ml) It's not a unique color but still very pretty and doesn't cost too much. That's the color for the one's who like lots of shimmer. It didn't burn my eyes at all.

Sephora Long Lasting Metallic Eyeliner Aubergine and Blue Review and Swatches

(0,082oz./2,3g) Comes with 7 lovely metallic shades. They won't smudge or transfer after they are dried. They will stay put for a good 15 hours, after that they will start flaking. They are very affordable, 10USD each. Unfortunately they burn my eyes a little bit. The applicator is very similar to the MAC Liquid Eyeliner. It's stiff, won't bend so it makes it very easy to draw a precise line.
Aubergine is a metallic plum color and blue is a metallic purple toned midnight blue.