Mac Lip Pencil in Embrace Me Review and Swatches

(1,45oz./0,05oz. - 15USD) This is basically just a neon pink lip liner. It's just toobright and looks childish to me, I got this in the store but it didn't seem right when I got back home. That's why I prefer online shopping, yes sometimes some pictures can decieve you but in the store those lights can deceive you too, at least you have the chance to compare with different lightning online.

MAC Lip Pencil in Redd Review and Swatches

(1,45g/0,05oz. - 14USD) I am a fan of Mac lip liners they are smooth, long lasting. But they have just a few color that appeals me, Redd is of them. It's a true matt red, not orangey red not brownish red. Pigmentation is good, one swipe is enough to show the color.

Shiseido Automatic Lip Crayon in LC1 and LC3 Review and Swatches

(1,5g/0,05oz. - 23USD) These could have been perfect lipsticks if only they had more pigmentation, already quite pigmented but not as intense as I'd like. They have a pearlescent effect to them, not appear on your lips though.They come in pencil form but won't  need sharpening because they are twist ups. I get around 4 hours of wear.
LC1 is a milky nude with a pink touch. Somewhat frosty and highly glossy.
LC3 is a strawberry pink. A bit sheer but becomes more opaque if you pile it on.

The Body Shop Lip Liner #13 Rosy Red Review and Swatches

(1,25g/0,04oz. - 10USD) The Body Shop lip liners are not the smoothest that I've tried, they are not bad though. They won't run quite easily. Rosy red is a red with some pinkyness to it, it's not truly opaque but almost there.
You have to watch out for it's ingredients, this small pencil contains 5 different parabens in it. Parabens make this pencil won't expire until 36 months, while they can make you cancer.